Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
Mystery
★ 5.2/102026–1 Season
Created by: Sandra L. Martin
After a breakup, Cheryl takes over an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek. Strange stuffed animals, a kidnapping, and hidden feuds force her, Naomi, and Levi into a thrilling search.
Status
Returning
Language
English
First Aired
Apr 23, 2026
Last Aired
Jun 11, 2026
Seasons
1
Episodes
9
Status
Returning
Language
English
First Aired
Apr 23, 2026
Last Aired
Jun 11, 2026
Seasons
1
Episodes
9
Episodes
Cast
Trailers & Clips
More Like This
6.8Harlan Coben's Shelter
2023 · Series
Harlan Coben's Shelter
6.8·2023
7.277 Sunset Strip
1958 · Series
77 Sunset Strip
7.2·1958
7.8Veronica Mars
2004 · Series
Veronica Mars
7.8·2004
6.2Agatha Raisin
2016 · Series
Agatha Raisin
6.2·2016
7.2The Girlfriend
2025 · Series
The Girlfriend
7.2·2025
7.9Agatha Christie's Marple
2004 · Series
Agatha Christie's Marple
7.9·2004
7.1Sugar
2024 · Series
Sugar
7.1·2024
8.5FROM
2022 · Series
FROM
8.5·2022
6.0High Country
2024 · Series
High Country
6.0·2024
8.1Sterling Point
2026 · Series
Sterling Point
8.1·2026
7.7Nancy Drew
2019 · Series
Nancy Drew
7.7·2019
7.7Nocturne
2026 · Series
Nocturne
7.7·2026
6.8Sherlock & Daughter
2025 · Series
Sherlock & Daughter
6.8·2025
6.7Whitstable Pearl
2021 · Series
Whitstable Pearl
6.7·2021
6.9Safe
2018 · Series
Safe
6.9·2018
6.9Mistletoe Murders
2024 · Series
Mistletoe Murders
6.9·2024
7.7Father Brown
2013 · Series
Father Brown
7.7·2013
7.1How to Get to Heaven from Belfast
2026 · Series
How to Get to Heaven from Belfast
7.1·2026
7.1Shakespeare & Hathaway - Private Investigators
2018 · Series
Shakespeare & Hathaway - Private Investigators
7.1·2018
7.1Cross
2024 · Series
Cross
7.1·2024